 |
Nick Miller: Figure to Ground, 1993-2003
Royal Hibernian Academy, 2003
pp.72. Large format p/b
e15/£10.70 ills 51 col
ISBN 1-903875-09-9
Readability: 4
Reference Use: 2
Design & Durability: 4
Quality of plates: 5
This
is a handsome volume retrospectively covering the past decade of Millers
practice. It consists of a brief interview by the RHAs director Patrick
T Murphy, and a well-written and informative essay by Catherine Marshall,
marred only by occasional emphatic generalizations (..the Italian
Renaissance opted for an idealised cerebral world..; or Millers
portrait of John McGahern described as the most challenging and finest
of Irish literary portraits. Really?). The plates are excellent, as
is the design but unfortunately there is no list of illustrations, making
reference difficult, and the bibliography, with reference to newspaper items,
does not give page references. Try ordering over inter-library loan without
a page reference and see what happens
Barbara Warren RHA: a retrospective,
Royal Hibernian Academy, 2002
pp.57, Square format p/b
e10/£7.20 ills 24 col
ISBN 1-903875-08-0
Readability: 4
Reference Use: 1
Design & Durability: 4
Quality of Plates: 3
This
is one of a series of exhibitions/ exhibition catalogues at the RHA that
document senior academicians who have been overlooked by the public gallery
system. I wouldnt really have thought that Barbara Warren was
overlooked but this catalogue wont help. Not only is there no index
or list of illustrations, which means that you have to keep flicking back
and forth through the catalogue to find the work that is being referred
to in the text, but just to ensure maximum annoyance, some works are referred
to but not given a title (one of which, naturally, is illustrated). To compound
matters, the bibliography is disapointing: six items are so incomplete you
couldnt order them through a library, however the illustrations are
good.
Paul Henry
S B Kennedy
National Gallery of Ireland/Yale University Press, 2003 Large format p/b
pp.150,
e25/£18.95 ills 122, mainly col
ISBN 0 300 09945
Readability: 4
Reference Use: 3
Design & Durability: 5
Quality of Plates: 0
The
primary text, by S B Kennedy, is an effective summary of his earlier biography
of the artist, supplemented by notes on each of the individual plates. The
appendices (with the exception of a non-existent list of illustrations)
are solid and scholarly: index, chronology, list of exhibitions and bibliography.
At which point the compliments stop. There is an additional essay entitled
The Formation of an Irish School of Painting: Issues of National Identity
by Sighle Bhreathnach-Lynch which is surprising, for all the wrong reasons.
The author points out that the new school of Irish landscape painting,
a school which, two paragraphs previously, we are told is difficult
to define because of the individualistic tendency of Irish artists, is almost
entirely a Northern-inspired affair. So, in other words, Northerners
were predominant in landscape but instead of trying to explore this within
its socio-political and historical context, lets just subsume the
lot of them into a [Southern] Irish nirvana, and while we are at it, at
the same time as proclaiming individualistic tendencies,
well ignore the fact that all these individuals happen to Northerners
and not Southerners.
But the worst problem however is that of the poor quality of the reproductions.
Walking through the exhibition with catalogue in hand, comparing the real
thing to the colour illustrations, is a saddening experience, especially
as the exhibition is timely, coherent, and cleverly selected. Its
not just a matter of the occasional bad plate. Almost all of them are tonally
wrong, and a substantial number are utterly wrong, so much so that in Low
Tide, for example, the original, in shades of pink, is rendered in the reproduction
as shades of light yellow. The problem of course is that the rest of the
world will view Henry in the light of reproductions which reduce his work
to the status of bad calendar art.
David King: pleasant places
Hallward Gallery, 2003
pp.32. Large oblong format p/b
e10/£7.20 ills 22 col
Readability: 4
Reference Use: 4
Design & Durability: 4
Quality of plates: 4
A
young painter specializing in landscape oils, this would seem to be his
first catalogue, and possibly his first solo show. The reproductions are
rather good and the brief essay by Roisin Kennedy is functional. The rather
truncated bibliography gives page references for two newpaper articles,
but not for the other three. No list of plates. |